More On The Demise of Manned Spaceflight

Posted: April 26, 2010 in China, Manned Space, Mars, Moon Shot, NASA, Uncategorized
Tags: ,

My basic knock on manned spaceflight regards the return on investment versus conventional (unmanned) space.  When a rational business model for manned space emerges, it will have a reasonable chance of success.  Until then, it won’t.  Space tourism is the current best chance for manned space and it will take some time before that capability evolves to interplanetary travel, if it ever does.

Some people think that going to the space station’s low-earth orbit is beneficial.  Beyond sustaining the space industrial base, it isn’t clear just how.  The space station and manned space itself looks a lot like a jobs program existing on its previous momentum, or alternatively, a program designed to placate space fans.

If you’re China and are desirous of the prestige associated with manned space flight that’s one thing.  After all, what are you going to spend all that cash on otherwise, human rights initiatives?  But if you are the U.S. with previous manned spaceflight success, low return on that success, and an onerous debt problem, manned spaceflight clearly falls into the ‘would like to do’ bin and not the ‘must do.’

This link closes with the estimate that a mission to Mars would cost $500 billion (likely w-a-y low) and NASA was recently plussed-up by…$6B.  Since there is no known compelling reason to have a manned mission to Mars, it will have to wait until conditions here on Earth have changed.

About these ads
Comments
  1. amanfromMars says:

    A manned Mars Space Simulation, whether that be as a Flight Vehicle [for extended Space Travel Experimentation] or Futuristic Space Base in a Virgin Environment [for Natural Sustainability with Alien Resource Management and Asset Recycling Programming Projects, for of course, there are no Manufacturing Capabilities or Husbandry Facilities in and/or on far away Planetary Objects ], in some Secluded and Secure Earth Area*, which could be Treated and Rigged to Function as a User Friendly Alien Time Zone/Advanced IntelAIgent Nation, would be a much more worthwhile Adventure for the Power and Control of the Human Mind and Imagination …. and Metadata and Help would be easily exchanged in an Instant.

    Creating an Alien Space on Earth is an Inhospitable Enough of a Unknown Known and a lot easier than flying off into the Great Void and the Known Unknown to find somewhere Alien and Inhospitable and which you cannot Instantly Communicate with for Help and Metadata Exchange.

    The new Lifestyle required for a Earthed Mars Station Simulator may Offer Earth Systems the Vital Change Information and Greater Intelligence that Humans need to Survive on Earth in AI and within Peaceful Coexistence Regimes.

    * 51?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s